Do the new Peeps-flavored Oreo cookies taste as terrible as they look?

We needed to know, so we held another Boris & Robyn Show live taste test to find out.

The new limited-edition cookies have just started to hit store shelves in the Hudson Valley. Just in time for Easter, Oreo has created a new version of their classic cookie using marshmallow Peeps flavoring in their creme center.

At first glance, the cookies look disgusting. The neon pink center is a ridiculous color that sends sugar-induced pain through your teeth just by looking at it. The chocolate Oreo cookies are replaced with vanilla, which I guess is supposed to pair better with pink than chocolate cookies would.

While these cookies look disgusting, we were all pretty surprised by the taste. Robyn and I were joined by newsman Bobby Welber and comedian Rich Shultis for the official tasting:

Have you tried the new Peeps flavored Oreo cookies yet? We'd love to know what you thought of them. Feel free to share your own review in the comments section below or on our Facebook page.