Popular Hudson Valley Stewart’s Shop has Closed for Good

Stewart's Shops has announced that it has permanently closed one of its Hudson Valley locations.

Customers who shop at the Stewart's Shop in Monticello, NY, will now have to travel a bit further to enjoy the great coffee, snacks, ice cream, milk products, and friendly service that fans have come to love about Stewart's Shops.

Stewart's Shop Closes in Monticello, NY?

Reports began circulating on social media that said the Stewart's Shop located at 12 Forestburgh Rd, in Monticello, NY, had shut down for good. To confirm the rumors, we contacted the store directly. An employee told us the location officially closed at 2:30 p.m. on Thursday, February 26th, 2026.

Why Did Stewart's Close?

According to a flyer distributed to customers, the Monticello store was no longer able to accommodate the equipment and space needed to expand its food offerings and additional services.

SEE ALSO: New York Lottery Players Win Big at Stewart's Shops

“We are choosing to close this location and refocus our efforts on serving our customers at other nearby locations,” the flyer stated.

The friendly employee we spoke to on Thursday did say they were sad that the store was permanently closed, but did invite everyone to visit them at the other Stewart’s Shops in the area.

Nearby Stewart's Shops

Stewart's Shops has nearby locations in Wurtsboro at 175 Kingston Ave., in Ellenville at 99 S. Main St., and in Fallsburg at 5 Brickman Rd.

While the Monticello location is now closed, Stewart’s continues to operate numerous stores throughout the Hudson Valley and Upstate New York, including locations in Dutchess, Ulster, Orange, and Sullivan Counties.